“my” against. “mine” for the multiple owner possessive

“my” against. “mine” for the multiple owner possessive

“We thus appreciate your providing my and you can Gregg’s man to school now.” – but I will suggest “the man” or even the kid’s label is natural than “my personal and you will Gregg’s guy”?

Whenever i agree with Warsaw Will, would it remain grammatically right to use “mine” in such a case, if you feel regarding “mine” since the writing about “my personal boy”? Which is, imagine if the initial phrase try it?:

– Ok, however, I believe Gregg’s kid will happen first in you to definitely situation to make obvious what “mine” is actually talking about:

In fact, it’s not precise on the modern whether we are speaking on a http://datingranking.net/korean-cupid-review/ couple of students. If it is one to, and speaker however desires speak about each other themself and you will Gregg, then i imagine “Gregg’s and you may my personal man” could be more natural than just “My and you will Gregg’s guy”. Whenever there’s two – I might favor “Gregg’s and you will my family”, I do believe.

Hi porsche, I’m however not so sure

– I am aware it isn’t everything you asked, although more I believe about this, the newest shorter reasoning We get a hold of to mention either Gregg otherwise me; the other person understands whoever man are involved. If we expose all of our girl to somebody Really don’t consider we constantly say, “That is Gregg’s and you will my personal girl”, however, often “This is our very own girl” or “This might be my personal daughter”. Subsequently, In my opinion we’d become more planning to say “my kid” otherwise “my personal girl” than just “my kid”, won’t i? Or while i said before, just have fun with the identity:

Towards the example provided on the totally new concern, my is right and you can mine grammatically impossible – others is merely design.

– I agree that that which you say is the treatment for new new concern, but the other people is not just regarding the design, it is more about sounding absolute. I recently do not think you to definitely “my and you may Gregg’s man” is actually absolute English. It does not sound if you ask me particularly anything a local presenter create say.

Tend to, I trust almost all that you told you, apart from things

You said that the first sentence is not too clear. I disagree. Most of the type put forth so far provides an extremely certain meaning:

can just only indicate the exact same thing. Several will say this is exactly ungrammatical, with “my” future earliest, in case not ungrammatical, it is at the least felt impolite from the the. It pronoun change is wholly unsuitable, in casual address. If you speak along these lines, everyone, “educated” or otherwise not, usually think you might be a young adolescent which cannot lay out their portable.

also can simply suggest Greg keeps a kid, you have a special child, and you may anyone grabbed both youngsters to school. Although this plus matical, it is still impolite. See the feedback over on “my”.

Mention, evey single one types is entirely unambiguous. Perhaps are common grammatical, however some are to be stopped having reasons mentioned.

Past, Tend to, your own remark in regards to the must speak about Greg is very better drawn. Specifically for cases where Greg and you have a kid together, it might be not likely to refer Greg after all (that makes it also crisper you to definitely “mine” meaans a few some other infants). Earliest, by the mentioning Greg, it’s about required that he’s perhaps not indeed establish. If that are the case, why must the guy be also said? You’ll simply say

I entirely agree totally that all the phrases you given is unambiguous, but they’ve been every result of our very own interpretation of unique phrase. Ok, given that sbee upcoming asks whether or not it will likely be ‘my’, he does inform you, however, if i take the completely new phrase because really stands instead of that opinion, i then however found it not sure. We thinkl that is what I implied.

Follow me!


メールアドレスが公開されることはありません。 * が付いている欄は必須項目です